Sunday, 9 Gathring (Wintring/Winterfilth), 2005
We have received a reply from the powers that be at the Metro Times regarding their decision to replace This Modern World and Red Meat: Unfortunately, it is their canned response - which they took a couple of weeks to fart toss in our general direction - but we thought we'd provide you with some of that independent confirmation sorta thing in case you were keeping score.
We're always glad when people feel strongly enough about the content of Metro Times to take the time to e-mail us. We have received many passionate letters about our decision to replace Red Meat and This Modern World with The Perry Bible Fellowship and The Boiling Point. This was a decision we did not make lightly. We wouldn't have run the work of Tom Tomorrow for more than 10 years and the work of Max Cannon for more than five years if we didn't like the strips. But we felt that Tom Tomorrow, who has been doing his strip for more than 20 years, has become so widely known and read that we began to question whether our mission was to provide a platform for somebody who is syndicated in scores of papers, has published several volumes of his cartoons, and is accessible on his own Web site. Similarly, Max Cannon has gained a national prominence and has published a few books of his collected work. The question wasn't whether the strips were any good -- clearly we have carried them so long because of their quality. What prompted the move was a larger debate on the function of alternative newsweeklies. Just as Tom Tomorrow and Max Cannon could never have reached audiences without the help of publications like Metro Times, we feel that we have a duty to present newer, younger cartoonists exploring new styles in the medium. It was with this in mind that we sought out fresh voices with a quality beyond their meager syndication. Mikhaela Reid is a 25-year-old political cartoonist for the Boston Phoenix and Bay Windows. Her work has appeared in a handful of national magazines. Editorial cartoonist Ted Rall says that, "Mikhaela B. Reid is, at the start of a promising career, already one of America's sharpest political cartoonists." Nicholas Gurewitch is a painter, actor, filmmaker and cartoonist living in New York state. Since winning the Baltimore City Paper's comic contest in 2003, his unusual strip has started appearing in several papers, including The New York Press. Last month, the strip won a jury prize at the Small Press Expo in Bethesda, MD for "Best Online Comic." Thank you for your thoughts on this matter, and we hope you can appreciate the factors that went into our decision. Needless to say, if you absolutely need your weekly fix of the wit of Tom Tomorrow and Max Cannon, their work is available electronically at thismodernworld.com and redmeat.com. Sincerely, The Editorial Staff of Metro Times |
We have absolutely nothing against either of the two fine cartoonists that have replaced Dan and Max*. We wonder why it isn't possible to include them all - then again, we're not involved in the process, and have no idea what would be involved in making sucha a decision (an extra page to fill? Might we suggest Amptoons or XQUZYPHYR and Overboard or Bruce Yurgil? Or all of them? Or a "Best of the Web" comics page with many different indy inkers each week? Perhaps a page of progressive cartoons which just might serve as a unique feature to capture a sadly neglected niche market?
You may recall that we sent them an email about their decision a couple of weeks ago. Have you sent yours**? And gotten this same reply? Inquiring minds want to know...
* - as a matter of fact, we have a personally autographed copy of Mihaela's first published collection, and we're planning on getting a copy of her second as well...
** - it would be preferable if you reside within the Metro Times distribution area when you send the email - it helps them to know you actually read the paper and provide them with some revenue. It would also be preferable if you were polite when you told the Metro Times how you feel about their decision...
Update: Interested readers could also check out this note from Tom Tomorrow regarding the situation. Apparently Dan doesn't buy their canned response so much.
Posted by (: Tom :) at October 4, 2005 04:56 AMAgreed. Cancelling those two strips was totally dick of the Metro Times. I'm going to drop an e-mail to the Metro Times myself as well as also put a post up on my site. I liked This Modern World.
Posted by: Ray Wert at October 16, 2005 11:56 AM